Solid Hero

Juror #8 is a dude that cares around justice and also is willing to stand up against a crowd to perform what he thinks is right. In the start, we"re not really sure what his deal is, bereason he starts kind of softly, saying, "Tbelow were eleven votes for guilty. It"s not so basic for me to raise my hand and also sfinish a boy off to die without talking about it initially." So at this early suggest, it sounds choose he simply desires to talk for a while prior to they reach a guilty verdict.

And, in reality, it doesn"t take long before the other jurors start pressing #8 to offer a Guilty verdict. They ascertain him that he"ll never before readjust their minds around the guilt of the defendant, however he responds by saying, "I don"t want to adjust your mind. I simply want to talk for a while. Look, this boy"s been kicked about all his life. You know, living in a slum, his mommy dead given that he was nine. That"s not a very excellent head begin. He"s a challenging, angry son. You understand why slum youngsters obtain that way?"

In various other words, this man thinks that the defendant deserves a small sympathy and conversation prior to the twelve jurors sfinish him off to die. But we sort of already know that he"s just biding his time and also angling to adjust some of the jurors" minds.

Not Just Moral, But Smart Too

Let"s be real: Juror #8 is probably also the smartest man in the jury room. When Juror #2 mentions that no one can prove the defendant didn"t commit murder, #8 is quick to answer, "Nobody has to prove otherwise. The burden of proof is on the prosecution. The defendant does not need to open up his mouth. That"s in the Constitution. The Fifth Amendment. You"ve heard of it."

And once Juror #10 claims that the jurors shouldn"t think the defendant bereason he"s not white, #8 asks, "How come you believed ? She"s one of "them," too, isn"t she?"

Regardless of every one of Juror #8"s tricky debates, he never before really gets any traction for a Not Guilty verdict till he mirrors the various other guys some solid proof. This sets us up for among the a lot of dramatic moments in the movie, as soon as #8 pulls a knife exactly choose the murder weapon out of his pocket and also jams it into the table, saying, "I acquired it last night in a tiny junk shop approximately the edge from the boy"s home. It cost 2 dollars."

On optimal of everything else we understand around him, we recognize that #8 has a little flair for the dramatic.

So, all right, Juror #8 is dramatic, just, sort, and also smart. But none of these things would gain him everywhere through the various other jurors if he weren"t willing to put himself out tbelow and take risks. He takes his best danger of all early in the movie as soon as he claims, "I desire to speak to for a vote. I desire you elalso guys to vote by trick ballot. I"ll abstain. If tbelow are still elalso votes for guilty, I will not stand also alone. We"ll take in a guilty verdict appropriate now."

If this vote as soon as aget went for a unanimous Guilty verdict, this movie would more than, and there"d be nopoint else to talk around. But Juror #8"s trust in his fellow male pays off, as Juror #9 gives a Not Guilty verdict and puts us all on the course to establishing the defendant cost-free.

Go For the Death Blow

Once Juror #8 has managed to sway a couple of of the jurors, it"s time for him to go on the offensive and strike the jurors whose prejudices prevent them from altering their minds. In one situation, he basically calls out Juror #3 for wanting to murder the defendant in cold blood by giving a Guilty verdict. He doesn"t mince words: "You desire to view this boy die bereason you personally want it—not bereason of the facts."

This tactic functions because #8 inevitably renders #3 so flustered that #3 tries to attack him; he also states he"ll kill him. To every one of this, #8 calmly answers, "You don"t really mean you"ll kill me, perform you?"—which reflects that we shouldn"t always believe world when they exaggeprice, certain, however it additionally mirrors that Juror #8 is able to stand approximately pretty much anything if he thinks his values are being violated.

By the end of the movie, Juror #8 has actually prcooktop himself to be a true hero for standing by his principles and having actually the courage and also ability to put them to job-related. He eventually gets the jury to uncover the defendant Not Guilty, and in the procedure, he avoids sfinishing an innocent 18 year-old boy to jail.


You are watching: Why does the foreman not want to give john henry a job at first?


See more: Why Did Sita Go Back To Earth

He additionally helps restore our faith in democracy and also human decency, which is pretty darn excellent for a day"s occupational.