The course webwebsite and also blog for the Fall 2016 circumstances of Penn State's SC200 course

MenuSkip to content
*

Question:

Does anyone else feel prefer everytime they eat breview they obtain a horrid situation of the hiccups???!!! I attempt and enjoy a slice of bcheck out, biscuit, roll, certain cakes, and so on, and also BAM…..hiccups. This happens to me all the time, and I simply can’t seem to number out why. Is it that I am eating it as well fast? Am I eating also much of it at once? Texture? Consistency? Ingredients? Am I allergic? What is going on?!!! Is tright here something personally wrong with me? It exceptionally well could be because of possibility, yet I understand that tbelow has to be a correlation in between my consumption of bprepared carbs and my hiccup attacks… or perhaps, not?

*

http://www.drbriffa.com/wp-content/uploads/2012/09/shutterstock_93060556.jpg

I’M NOT NUTS:

If you think I’m crazy and are analysis this like “What is this girl talking about? I’ve never before heard of getting hiccups from bread”, well, I’m not alone. Check out this attach to read around some other pissed bcheck out eaters:

http://www.homesteadingthis particular day.com/general-homesteading-forums/countryside-families/442856-does-bread-give-you-hiccups.html

This proves no evidence or assistance to a causation, however reflects that this is a legit question that other human being are asking too.

You are watching: Why do i get the hiccups when i eat bread

Suggestive Correlations:

Breview → hiccups (direct causality) …..what i think is happening Bcheck out ← hiccups (reverse causality)…. Not what i think is happening… having actually the hiccups does not make me eat bread…… this causation is ruled out…. I am simply stating it to narrowhead it downBcheck out ← Z → Hiccups (Confounding)…. Anything that could reason hiccups and also bread consumption…(examples provided below)Chance….always can be a possibility

What’s going on:

I think the majority of the reason that I am so perplexed regarding why I get these sudden hiccups is because I am not all that educated on what a hiccup actually is. So, I did some study. According to a medical professor at the University of Calgary, William A. Whitelaw, tright here are various happenings in the body that cause them. He claims that the leading cause is initiated by the stomach widening and also sending its’ acids up through the throat. This allegedly causes the diaphragm to have actually a spasm and also easily contract together with multiple other muscles in the throat consisting of the vocal cords. This sudden activity causes the sound of a hiccup, and the rush of air up the esophagus reasons a secondary “burp-like” experience. Ok, so now I recognize how a hiccup is developed, good, however this still does not answer why on earth bread seemingly provides this phenomenon take place in my body.

So I dug a tiny deeper……. Confounding Variables:

Along the means in my study, I uncovered some even more certain reasons of the hiccup process– ones that might narrow dvery own why bread in particular does this to me. According to a pojiyuushikan.orggar fitness blog, other reasons incorporate consumption of spicy foodstuffs, carbocountry, alcohol, tobacco, and also air. Maybe some of these can even be feasible 3rd variables. Maybe i tend to eat even more bread when I’m eating spicy foods to lessen the extreme seasonings. Alcohol or carbonated drinks favor soda can also be conbeginning variables because regularly soda or alcohol is a preferable beverage choice to pair through bcheck out. The article also suggests that speedy eating and also overeating deserve to cause hiccups, but tright here is no scientific proof to declare a device.

Another interesting correlation is proclaimed in Dr. Oz and Dr. Roizen’s write-up about Celiac illness. In simple terms they defined the illness as a devastation of a lining in the intestines that prevents the capacity for nutrients to circulation with the body. Due to the fact that of the damage, the stomach’s of Celiac condition patients have actually trouble accepting gluten in any form. In result, hiccup outbursts may take place. From this information, it can be suggested that gluten might be a possible cause for hiccups, but the perchild eating the bcheck out has to be a Celiac patient… or carry out they? Tbelow is no published proof.

Experimentation….or absence tbelow of:

From the looks of my study, it appears the majority of probable that the correlation in between bread and hiccups is resulted in by a third variable. However, given that tright here is no previous or publimelted control experiments for this hypothesis, I cannot state a conclusion that has enough proof. If I were to produce an experiment to test this question, I would execute a regulate experimental trial. The participants would be separation accordingly right into two teams with an equal number of males and also females in each group. The human being in the manage team would be Celiac-totally free and would certainly each quickly eat 3 slices of white breview. The speculative group would be Celiac patients and would conveniently eat 3 pieces of white bcheck out. If the results proved that within 5 minutes after the bcheck out usage only one of the teams obtained hiccups, then the proof might assistance that either the gluten or the fast-eating resulted in the hiccups. I would certainly then carry out the precise same trial yet have actually the bcheck out be consumed progressively. If the original outcomes verified that within 5 minutes after the bread intake both groups acquired hiccups, then I would run another trial. This trial would certainly be precisely the exact same, yet I would certainly switch the y-variable from white breview to gluten cost-free bread and execute the exact same article procedure as the initially trial.

Is bcheck out guilty?

It turns out that the correlation between bread and also hiccups is much more facility than I had actually assumed. I apologize to bcheck out for pointing the finger. It is not fair for me to blame bcheck out for my hiccups. However, as a result of the absence of testing and proof, I am still cynical of bcheck out.

See more: Ask Sam Farmer: Why Do Quarterbacks Call Out The Mike, : Explainlikeimfive

But since I do not have actually Celiac condition, and tright here are so many kind of feasible z-variables that could reason my hiccups, I’m going to say “the heck with it!” and also keep eating breview.

Article Sources:

https://www.scientificamerideserve to.com/article/what-causes-hiccups/

http://www.kansas.com/living/health-fitness/article1092152.htmlhttp://www.pojiyuushikan.orggar.com/fitness/What-Causes-Hiccups-433061