According to multiple reports, positive pregnancy tests are obtainable for purchase on Craigslist. Why would someone sell such a point, and also why would certainly anyone purchase it? The answer to both concerns, according to legal professionals, might not only be immoral and also unethical, however criminal. Outside the world of soap opperiods, faking pregnancy have the right to be a crime.

You are watching: Why do females lie about being pregnant

Just prior to Labor Day, Courtney and also Irvin Murrell were sentenced to jail time for pretending that Courtney miscarried twins. The Murrells bilked miscellaneous friends, acquaintances and employers out of money for funeral expenses and also other various expenses linked through the fabricated pregnancy and miscarriage. One of the victims was the mother of among Courtney’s previous boyfriends, whom she called as the father of the missing youngsters.

According to criminal defense attorney Pamela Mackey, finest well-known for representing basketball player Kobe Bryant in a high-profile rape instance, women that mislead males in their stays for financial obtain in the method the Murrells did can challenge equivalent legal ramifications. She sassist such actions constitutes “theft by deception. If you deceive someone into offering you money, that’s a crime.”

“I don’t care what you usage it for. Not my business! : )”

Former prosecutor-turned-criminal defense attorney Seema Iyer explained that in New York, wright here one of the Craigslist ads for positive pregnancy tests showed up, “acting in a fraudulent manner to obtain property” is a violation of fraud statutes and a criminal offense. So, if a womale tells a existing or former companion she is pregnant once she isn"t and also researches financial assistance to deal with said pregnancy in any type of means, shape or develop, she is breaking the law. In enhancement to being in violation of this “plan to defraud” statute, she might also be accprovided of violating New York’s criminal impersonation statute. Iyer read the statute as follows: “A person is guilty of criminal impersocountry once they impersonate another and also in such assumed character with intent to attain a advantage or to injure or defraud another.” But realistically, though a prosecutor could pursue someone for either fraud or criminal impersocountry, Iyer sassist a woman in this instance would many most likely be prosecuted for basic harassment or larceny, which is the legal term for theft.

But what if the woman is in a permanent relationship and also, instead of making explicit financial repursuits, obtains something else—choose a marriage proposal? “That could be the basis in divorce court,” Iyer shelp. “Due to the fact that in civil court you are trying to obtain some non-incarceratory repair.”

Famed celebrity divorce attorney Raoul Felder agreed. Felder has represented notables like previous New York City mayor Rudolph Giuliani, and also is currently representing rock star Liam Gallagher, formerly of Oasis, in a paternity and also son support instance. When asked about the sale of positive pregnancy tests, Felder replied, “I think it’s a new wrinkle on an old scamera.” He added that in the old days, some women would say, “I’m pregnant. I need to eliminate the baby. It’s going to cost me $2,500” and also might tell this to multiple men for financial get. “This is a 2013 . This is corroboration as well.”

Felder described that corroboration is necessary, bereason historically such instances ddeveloped right into a “he-sassist, she-said” conflict once it came time to type out the facts. But ordering a test on Craigslist would most likely develop a document trail, making it easier to create fraud, and also premeditation.

Echoing Iyer’s interpretation of the legislation, Felder defined that someone utilizing a fake pregnancy to achieve financial benefits from someone she is not married to would certainly be committing “larceny by trick or tool. They tricked someone out of money. That’s a criminal offense.” But if a pair marries, and also the marriage was based on a lie about pregnancy, “That’s what they contact fraud in the inception or fraud in the inducement if you obtain married.” Such a situation is equivalent to couples that divorce or look for annulment on the grounds that one spouse lied to the various other around wanting to have actually kids in order to enter the marriage.

But Felder believes that purchasing a fraudulent pregnancy test constitutes “an overt act—and also potential conspiracy also.” He is not the only one.

See more: ★: When You Are Tired Your _________ Shrinks., Drivers Ed Course Test Q&As: Done

Of those marketing the pregnancy tests, Maccrucial shelp, “I would certainly hazard to guess that an imaginative prosecutor would certainly attempt to pursue someone prefer that on complicity, conspiracy, and aiding and also abetting,” even more explaining that those terms incorporate “criminal licapability once rerelocated.”

“A conspiracy is basically an organization whose objective is to commit some sort of unlawful activity,” Iyer described. “You can conspire to offer drugs. You can conspire to sell false pregnancy tests.” An instance would certainly be if a womale agreed to offer her positive pregnancy test to another woman who explicitly shelp she would use it to target miscellaneous men for money and would certainly split the succeeding proceeds through the woguy that sold her the test. Iyer compared faking pregnancy to prostitution, in that both the buyer and seller have the right to potentially be open to prosecution.

Perhaps sensing shaky legal ground, one Craigslist pregnancy test seller made a point to say in her posting: