Parenting is constantly a debatable topic in America. Every perboy has an opinion on just how a son have to be increased and disciplined. In Amy Chua’s “Why Chinese Mothers Are Superior” (an excerpt from Battle Hymn of the Tiger Mother), Chua explains Chinese parenting and also exactly how it is efficient in her life. She clintends that by breaking dvery own a kid and also pushing them to their full potential, the child will certainly, consequently, be confident and also very successful. Through the use of numerous rhetorical tools, Chua supports, as well as weakens, her claim and also expresses a different, controversial method of parenting.

You are watching: Why chinese mothers are superior by amy chua summary


Turn in your highest-top quality paper Get a qualified writer to assist you with
“ Rhetorical Analysis – “Why Chinese Mothers Are Superior” ”
Get high-quality paper
NEW! AI equivalent through writer

An vital element in Chua’s argument is her ethos. She is plainly an intellectual individual, given that she is a professor at Yale University. Putting aside her credentials, this essay brings forth a distinct character. From the begin, she identifies herself as a tough and strict “Chinese mother”. Throughout the piece she provides a number of personal experiences that support this assertion.


Get top quality aid now
*

writer-marian
*
Verified writer

Proficient in: Culture


*
*
*

+84 appropriate specialists are online
Hire writer

The reader recognizes a feeling of confidence from Chua as she repeatedly contrasts Western-parenting ideals from Chinese-parenting ideals. As much as her credibility as an writer, it is questionable. She writes, “ Chinese parents think that their children owe them every little thing.

The reason for this is a little unclear…” Her credibility starts to slip once she provides the word “unclear”. This statement says that she does not also know herself why she is parenting the method she is parenting. It additionally presents a perfect opportunity for opposing world to make an dispute versus Chua’s style of parenting.


Get to Kcurrently The Price Estimate For Your Paper
Topic
Deadline: 10 days left
Number of pages
EmailInvalid email
By clicking “Check Writers’ Offers”, you agree to our regards to organization and also privacy plan. We’ll periodically sfinish you promo and account related email


"You should agree to out terms of services and privacy policy"
Check writers" offers

You won’t be charged yet!


Anvarious other instance wbelow Chua’s credibility becomes uncertain is when she writes of mimicking her husband also when he intervenes in a conflict between her and also their daughter. It shows that she is unwilling to listen to the various other side of her debate and also has this my-way-or-the-highmethod complex—which is not necessarily an attrenergetic outlook to have actually. It appears that an author who is open up to looking at both sides of an discussion is a more respectable author.

Chua’s usage of pathos is particularly insensitive. She provides it more to take a jab at Western culture quite than to make an appeal on either side. Several times Chua provides up these hypothetical scenarios and also discusses what Western parental fees would execute and also then what Chinese parental fees would do. Her concept of just how Western parental fees react is seemingly dead on but tbelow is a sarcastic tone around it. What is really amazing around her emotional appeal is that she quotes her husband that opposes one facet of her dispute. He states, “Children don’t choose their parents…so it’s the parents’ responsibility to provide for them,” which is an appeal to Western paleas. She automatically shuts his debate dvery own however falls short to explain why it is “a disastrous deal for the Western parent.” This only weakens her claim bereason, again, she is not being open-minded. In the end, Chua provides an extremely general appeal by saying, “All decent parents desire to do what’s ideal for their children.” It is confutilizing bereason this statement somewhat qualifies her claim. First, she refutes Western parenting, then, comes ago to say that Western and Chinese paleas are all one in the same in the method that they care for their kids. Chua’s motive is unclear.

Beyond Chua’s solid opinions, she utilizes statistics and also facts in her argument. The statistics at the beginning of the piece explain percenteras of Western and also Chinese mothers that agreed that “‘stressing academic success is not great for children’ or that ‘paleas have to foster the principle that discovering is fun.’” The outcome confirmed that 0% of Chinese mothers agreed and they, rather, valued the idea of successful youngsters resulting from successful parenting. These types of statistics certainly assistance Chua’s “Chinese mother” persona. The statistics likewise sustained her claim of exactly how a lot time Chinese paleas put right into helping their kids make academic achievements. It is challenging to argue via facts and also information, yet, Chua does not mention the resources of this data. For all the reader knows, she can have actually made it up. It may be a more useful logical appeal if the studies she quotes were from a famous and respected source.

Chua’s alternative of diction shows feasible exaggeration on Chua’s befifty percent and confusion for the reader. It renders sense to exaggerate in order to tension the allude she is trying to make but it also triggers the reader to doubt and also question, which does not help her cause. Referring to her daughter, she writes, “calling her garbage…as soon as she acted very disrespectcompletely toward me.” The principle of someone acting “extremely disrespectfully” varies from perkid to perboy. It is incredibly biased statement. Tright here is no method to interpret just how her daughter was really acting. Alprepared having examples of Chua’s ethos from this item, it is helpful to assume she is exaggerating. Chua’s diction is also troubling, particularly when she writes, “All decent paleas desire to execute what’s best for their children.” What are “decent parents” and what is “best” for any kind of child? She does not sophisticated on these essential terms. It is the beginning of an dispute on meaning. Like in the instance of Chua’s exaggeration, tbelow is no way to identify what attributes a great parent has. Tbelow is no way for eextremely parent to agree on a list of things that are finest for kids.

Anvarious other method the writer uses to gain her allude throughout is repetition. Many times throughout her essay Chua repeats two words at the beginning of a sentence, “By contrast…” She is making it incredibly clear that there are differences in between Western paleas and also Chinese parental fees. This is effective bereason the reader is constantly reminded that these 2 types of parents are not similar in Chua’s mind. There is additionally a bit of repetition in terms of actions of the writer. It seems choose tright here is a cycle of Chinese parenting in her life. She raised her daughters the method her parents raised her. Chua’s father dubbed her “garbage” once she acted incorrect and Chua called her daughter “garbage” once she acted inappropriate. This cycle of Chinese parenting suggests that Chinese society is unaltering or very hard to adjust. Overall, through repetition, the reader gets an excellent feeling of contrasting societies.

The intended audience for this argument is an aspect worth stating. Chua was a lot of likely aiming this piece particularly at Western parents. The argument is definitely eye-recording to any parent and also is compelling sufficient to spark disagreement. Chua seems to want that reactivity because the objective of her essay wregarding comparison Chinese parenting and also Western parenting and describe how Chinese parenting is more effective—in her opinion. It virtually appears as though she desires to rub it in the deals with of Western parental fees, perhaps also spark guilt. The effect she wants to have actually on her audience might be for them think around her claim and reevaluate their methods of parenting.

See more: How Do You Ask Someone Their Name In Spanish, How To Ask Someone'S Name In Spanish

As pointed out prior to, Chua clintends that by criticizing a son and hammering academic success right into his or her brain the boy will grow to come to be a flourishing and confident person. Her purpose gets via to the audience yet does not necessarily persuade them. She utilizes rhetorical tools that both assistance and also weaken her dispute. Chua’s lifestyle is a result of just how she was raised. In a sense, her item is an excellent leschild for Western societies around Chinese culture. Chua may or may not properly describe why Chinese mothers are exceptional yet, eventually, she conveys a distinct, if not completely outrageous, concept of parenting directed at the average Western paleas.