Conservation and also conservation might seem favor the exact same thing, but tbelow are necessary distinctions. The National Park Service points out that while both terms involve some level of defense, conservation “looks for the appropriate use of nature,” while preservation “looks for the protection of nature from usage.”

As a young girl, the wall surfaces of my room were plastered through wildlife photos torn from the peras of Ranger Rick magazines. Stickers fostering everything from Smocrucial the Bear to the Crying Indian decorated the sides of a edge cabinet. I invested my totally free time experimenting the woods around our small farm, knowing early on that I wanted to help save the untouched areas wbelow wildlife made their residence.

As an adult, I am fortunate to live out my passion, working for a land trust and also saving land. As we think around the viewpoint of our work, larger concerns are asked - what are we conserving, who are we conserving it for, and are we conserving or preserving?

I think earlier to John Muir and also Gifford Pinchot. Both were leaders in the at an early stage eco-friendly activity of the 1ninth century, yet the 2 males hosted extremely various views. Muir saw wilderness as a location to be revered and safeguarded from the intrusion of humanity. Pinchot, on the various other hand also, was a pioneer in Amerideserve to foresattempt who observed wilderness as a organic resource to be wisely provided and also controlled for financial gains.

You are watching: What is true about conservation versus preservation

The Foremainder Reserve Act of 1891 empowered presidents of the USA to set aside parcels of public land as nationwide woodland reserves. The Ken Burns film series, “The National Parks; America’s Best Idea”, describes just how Muir taken into consideration woodlands spiritual and also wanted them treated as parks, with logging, grazing, and hunting prohibited, while Pincwarm suggested these lands need to be supplied and managed like a crop, not maintained like a holy place.

Pinchot's "utilitarian" forest conservation technique won favor with Congress at the time. National Forests ended up being part of the Department of Agriculture, via Pinchot appointed as the nation’s first chief forester, in 1898.

Muir’s activism, on the various other hand, among various other conservation victories, helped secure the facility of Yosemite National Park in 1890 and also the conservation of Mount Rainier, the majority of which was initially had within the borders of the 1893 Pacific Foremainder Reserve wbelow logging and grazing would certainly have been allowed. After years of advocacy, Muir and his allies prospered, and also Mount Rainier National Park was establiburned in 1899. Muir, that co-established the Sierra Club in 1892, ended up being known as the “Father of the National Parks”.


Although Muir and Pinchot began a friendship and discovered common ground in the early on years, their friendship finished in 1897 with public clashes over such worries as lamb grazing in national woodlands and the damming and flooding of the glacial Hetch Hetchy Valley, part of Yosemite National Park, by the city of San Francisco.

Differing views and tension over the usage and also treatment of natural areas proceeds this particular day. On a neighborhood range, the damming of streams, commercial agriculture in sensitive watersheds, and the kind and also density of trail advance in natural areas all have actually spurred dispute on some level. Those sustaining the usage or broadened use of herbal areas for huguy consumption or enjoyment can frequently suggest to substantial financial gains and community advance benefits, while those who advocate for preservation plead the intrinsic value of saving nature for nature’s sake and keeping wild areas wild.

There is a place for both, and also balance is vital. A balanced method is favored by the land also trust in making land use decisions. An increated balance. Even Muir recognized that the taking of lumber from particular areas was crucial to huguy survival. The crucial point is to understand the distinction and to ask the right questions - is this the best point to execute, appropriate here, right currently, and also what are the future implications? (How do we recognize the answers? For more on that, watch for Part 2 of this Good Stewards blog series, “Broadening the Lens”.)

As for me, a spiroutine and transcendental see of nature resonates deep within my spirit and also always has actually. Humans can be short-sighted and self-focused. It’s simple to view nature “for me” and also fail to see the worth in simply letting it be. But nature is the extremely location, once approached via gratitude and an open up soul, that allows one to attach via something higher than ourselves. Nature gives in means that can’t all be measured. Sometimes, we need to preserve the holy place.

The above blog is the initially in a collection on land stewardship. Stay tuned for upcoming installments. As constantly, your feedearlier is welcome - let’s have a conversation around caring for our natural areas in Northwest Arkansas.

See more: I Would Like To Personally Thank You, For Your Excellent Service

Terri Lane is Executive Director & CEO of the Northwest Arkansas Land Trust, a local nonprofit based in Fayetteville, Arkansas. She has operated in the ecological area for over twenty years, serving at the helm of the land also trust for eight. She uses her suffer and also passion towards conserving the landscapes that issue a lot of in the Ozark Highlands and Boston Mountain ecoareas of Northwest Arkansas.