About UsOur ApproachPrograms & ResourcesProfessional DevelopmentResourcesReresources and also Leschild PlansThe Re-Imagining Migration ToolkitThinking Routines for a World on the MoveContact Us

Analyzing Anti-Immiapprove Attitudes in Political Cartoons

by Adam Strom

We are living in a paradoxical moment, while all trustworthy data suggests that immigrants are integrating as rapid, or faster than in previous generations, anti-immigrant rhetoric and also violence appear to be on the climb. Maybe that is to be intended. Throughout periods of mass migration, newcomers have frequently been met via skepticism and distrust. Beyond the predictability of prejudice, an informed observer will certainly recognize that many kind of of the stereotypes directed at immigrants this day echo those that were used to label immigrants in the past.

You are watching: What form of media did nativists use to turn public opinion against newer immigrants?

We think that one method to empower young world is to aid them get a perspective on current occasions by emerging their historical expertise. They have the right to learn from the previous that tright here are patterns of prejudice that we have the right to identify and also the ability to make well-reasoned historic connections —recognizing what is familiar from a examine of the previous, and also what is new and unique to our existing minute — is a critical ability for both young world and also adults.

Tbelow are many methods to present backgrounds of anti-immiprovide prejudices. As an educator, I choose to use main sources and straight quotations as much as possible.

Here are a couple of points to think about:

Encountering prejudice, also in language stings, and also it may sting for some of your students even more than others bereason of who they are, what they have proficient, and what they have actually or not been exposed to.Tbelow is always a hazard of introducing stereotypes while you are attempting to determine and eradicate them. For that factor, tright here are educators I respect that choose not to present primary sources from perpetrators of prejudice right into the classroom. Obviously, I am suggesting a different approach: decreating them.How have you contracted for the discussion? Are tright here words that are off limits? If so, students should understand that ahead of time and also the reasons behind those decisions.

For this leskid, I selected a variety of anti-immiapprove cartoons. You should choose your imperiods closely. Don’t simply pick the finest images: remember your teaching objectives, understand your students, and also make sure the images you selected are representative of duration and perspectives you hope to present, and also finally, make sure you recognize about the sources of your image. It is extremely challenging to recognize the intent of a political cartoonist if you don’t know the period in which they worked or the audiences they hoped to affect.

Thinking around Media:

I might begin by asking students to think about the relationship between imperiods and principles they encounter in media (social media, entertainment, news, etc) and the way they think and act. While many civilization think they are immune to the influence of media on their actions, almost every one of us can think of times once we felt that a group we are component of was unreasonably illustrated in media. Additionally, researchers have found aacquire and aobtain a connection in between usage of stereokinds from assorted media and also the way world behave actually in the real world.

“Throwing Dvery own the Ladder by Which They Rose, by Thomas Nast, 23 July 1870

Why Political Cartoons?:

For much of the history of the United States print, newspapers and also magazines, in specific, was the dominant develop of media. In the late 19th and also turn of the 20th century, substantial cities in the United States frequently had actually several competing newspapers via different editorial points of view. Tright here were also renowned magazines via national circulation, such as Harper’s Weekly. Those media outlets help to structure the means world believed about the people in which they were living. One excellent resource for thinking around these worries is a robust blog around the job-related of the illustrator Thomas Nast.

Historical Context:


Italian Immigrants at Ellis Island also, 1905

From the arrival of the First Nations of native peoples, to European explorers seeking treacertain and also religious flexibility, to the mass involuntary migrations of enslaved Africans, to the trans-oceanic movements of yesterday and also the continuous international migrations of today, migration specifies the Amerideserve to suffer. Many kind of scholars explain that tbelow have been waves of migration that have actually ebbed and also flowed over time. Those ebbs and also flows have actually been a result of push components that have actually led migrants to leave their homes (consisting of violence, poverty, and also force), pull factors that have actually made the United States a destination, legal constraints on immigration, and anti-immigrant perspectives.

The political cartoons in this leschild are from the mid to late 19th and also beforehand 20th century. This duration is known as both a time of mass migration to the U.S. Migrants to the nation discovered both brand-new opportunities and also nativism and anti-immigrant prejudice. You can contextualize this leschild by introducing a timeline or a summary of the history of migration to the USA. Below I’ve established a few resources that you can discover useful as you think around the historic context.

See more: What Are The Effects Of Intentional Virus Setting A, What Is Intentional Virus Setting

Examining and also Interpreting Political Cartoons:

In this leskid, we will ask students to analyze political cartoons to recognize fads of anti-immiprovide stereotypes. It is vital to convey to students that political cartoons are intfinished to have an editorial allude of view. Because of this the cartoonist is shaping their message in order to influence the means their reader thinks and acts in relation to an problem. In practically eexceptionally among the cartoons, negative stereoforms are installed in the editorial message.

Below we have curated a selection of anti-immigration cartoons for use in this lesboy. Click on a photo to scroll via the images or use the pagination on the lower left of the gallery.

This is component of our Media Highlight Series which aims to assistance curriculum around migration via the exploration of storytelling – this consists of literary works, film and more.