Do you think that the phrase: there have to constantly be a stark in winterfell has actually a more substantial maybe magical definition through regards to the white walkers or ?

Hey, nonnie!

“Tright here need to always be a Stark in Winterfell” hankers back to the times once Starks were the Kings in the North. It’s a motto that helps sepaprice the Starks from the various other noble dwellings of the North bereason they’re even more than that. They are basically the royal household of the North and also Winterdropped is their seat of power. So this saying is there to signal their condition and also the prominence of Winterdropped.

You are watching: There must always be a stark in winterfell theory

The Starks are also important to the North because of Winterdropped and also the hot springs that exist beneath the castle. Winterfell becomes the facility of the migration of the Northern populace during winter as its their finest chance of survival versus the harsh weather, hence the visibility of Winter Town, a place that is largely populated throughout winter. So the Starks are shepherding this incredibly vital location that is vital to the entirety of the North.

However, considering a magical explanation for this motto and also Winterdropped in its entirety is absolutely somepoint worth entertaining for several reasons:

Winterdropped is meant to have actually been developed by Bran the Builder, the mythical figure that also elevated the Wall. The Wall surface is, of course, imbued through magical characteristics that allow it not just to stand however also actively stop the White Walkers from advancing on the rest of Westeros. It’s not external the realms of opportunity that tright here is some magic at play in Winterdropped too given that it started being developed at around the same time.

I have actually checked out it speculated that Winterfell’s purpose is in reality as a weapon of sorts against the WWs. How that weapon could be deployed is anyone’s guess at this time however I do find the idea really compelling

If we look at the map listed below we deserve to actually check out that Winterdropped is placed strategically, even more or less in the middle of the Northern territory:


Which is why Sansa says in seaboy 7 that no issue wbelow the threat originates from, Winterdropped is the ideal place to be in order to mount a defense. I don’t think this area was liked by accident.

Housage Stark has actually an extremely solid link to magic. All the Stark youngsters, including Jon, are wargs. I understand we don’t see Sansa and also Robb warging their wolves but I assume that’s bereason Lady was eliminated before Sansa became aware of her warging abilities and also we don’t have actually accessibility to Robb and also Rickon’s POV in the publications. But I think it’s safe to assume they would certainly have actually underwent the exact same forms of experiences as Jon and Arya perform.

There are additionally stories that paint the Stark ancestors as magical. The the majority of crucial of these stories is the story of the 13th Lord Commander of the Night’s Watch that lugged on an affair for years with what is intended to be a female White Walker, produced youngsters that were then handed over to the WWs as sacrifices. The twist in that story originates from Old Nan who identifies this figure as being the brother of the Stark of Winterfell at the time. Which suggests that some of the WWs, perhaps also the Night King can actually be Starks themselves. In the present we see the guy that becomes the Night King being turned by the Children of the Forest. They could attach this earlier to the 13th Lord Commander in seaboy 8 and also disclose that the Night King is, in fact, a Stark. It would certainly be a very exciting twist to the story.

The old monarchs in the crypts are also an exciting aspect of this magical link between the Starks and Winterdropped. These are the numbers that seem to be rejecting Jon in his desires. They are hidden towards the lowest level of the crypts, almost as if they’ve been surprise away. They sit on thrones, with iron swords over their laps and also guarded by stone wolves. The detail of the iron swords is interesting bereason we understand from Old Nan that the White Walkers hate iron for whatever before factor. So while those swords could be there in order to signal the Kings of Winter fighting the WWs, they can additionally be there to save the Kings trapped in the crypts, comparable to the means you save a vampire trapped by running an iron nail with its heart.

It is additionally very exciting that the Starks would certainly pick to bury all of their dead in this crypt that spans many kind of levels, in a territory that still spreads stories concerning creatures of ice increasing the dead to revolve them against the living. You’d think they’d take on a legacy of burning equivalent to what is happening in the South however no, they save at it and save including bodies dvery own there. I think it’s pretty much a offered some of those Stark ancestors will be crawling out of their tombs as soon as the Night King gets to Winterfell, which renders the scenes in the trailer of Arya in the crypts and also the team of human being hiding dvery own there in the Varys clip all the even more intriguing. I’m guessing some zombie slaughter is about to go down in those crypts.

See more: Why Do You Want To Work At Accenture Is A Great Place To Start Your Career

So, nonnie, the short answer is yes, I think there’s a pretty good possibility there is some magical association for the motto of“Tbelow should always be a Stark in Winterfell” and it hregarding do through the connection between the Starks and also the magic of the old gods, Winterfell itself and also the feasible kinship that could exist in between the Starks and the White Walkers.