My Heart Has a Mind of Its Own

Sometimes, even time cannot heal a wounded heart

Posted January 15, 2012

"The heart has actually its reasons which reason does not understand." Blaise Pascal"I told this heart of mine our love could never beBut then I hear your voice and also somepoint stirs inside of meSomeexactly how I can not withstand the memory of your kissGuess my heart has actually a mind of its very own." Connie Francis

"You know what, tright here is a place you can touch a woguy that will drive her crazy ... her heart." Melanie Griffith

Emotional thinking, which prevails in matters of the heart, is various from intellectual thinking. Are these 2 forms of reasoning condemned to fight each various other, or have the right to they be integrated? Should we follow our heart entirely in romantic matters, and are we able to stand up to it even if we want to? Pundit thinking is wider than emotional reasoning: it refers to a more comprehensive scope of situations and also has even more flexibility in the perspectives that it can adopt in its evaluation. The ethics underlying emotional and intellectual reasonings are ethics of information processing that determine the definition of events approximately us. Two examples of the emotional system"s principles are:

1. Changes are even more considerable than stability;

2. A individual occasion is even more considerable than a non-personal occasion.

You are watching: My heart has a mind of its own

Corconnected principles of the intellectual device are:

1. Changes are not even more substantial than stability; on the contrary, we have to assume that tbelow are secure regularities in the world;

2. A personal occasion is not necessarily more meaningful than a non-individual event.

What is the connection between the systems?Commenting on La Rochefoucauld"s maxim that "The head is constantly fooled by the heart," Jon Elster asks why the heart have to bvarious other to fool the head. Why can"t the heart just acquire on via whatever it desires to do? The answer he argues is that it is a vital part of our self-image that we believe ourselves to be swayed by factor rather than by passion. Elster terms this tendency "addiction to reason" and rightly clintends that it renders those that are so addicted irrational fairly than rational. A rational person knows that under certain problems it is much better to follow emotional tendencies than to usage more elaborate intellectual procedures.

Sometimes the oppowebsite tendency is noticeable as well: People present their calculated actions as if they were contrary to intellectual thinking and also in accordance through the ethical regulates of their hearts, bereason they wish to seem passionate. Politicians, that frequently behave in a calculated and imethical manner, typically use this tactic.

The evaluative systems underlying emotional and intellectual thinking can be discerned by their mechanisms and also contents. Whereas the emotional system frequently supplies a spontaneous device and also its content is narrowhead (and also partial), the intellectual system is frequently deliberative and also has actually a more comprehensive perspective. The emotional model that might define intuitive emotional understanding is that which describes expert knowledge. Like emotional expertise, experienced understanding is intuitive in the sense that it is not based on a careful intellectual analysis of the provided data, yet quite on activating specific (gained and also innate) cognitive frameworks. The famous Amerideserve to architect Frank Lloyd Wappropriate said that "an skilled is one that does not have to think; he knows." Like expert expertise, emotional knowledge that originates from the heart is a type of sensitivity to specific kinds of higher-level stimuli.

In a comparable manner, Daniel Kahneman has actually said separating in between two units of processing, calling them intuition and also reasoning respectively. Intuition (mechanism 1), is based upon emotional reasoning; reasoning (device 2) is based upon intellectual thinking. The two kinds of logic are not totally contradictory and have actually certain prevalent values.

Integrating the 2 reasoning units is difficult to attain, yet it is practical. This integration, which is termed by psychologists "Emotional Intelligence," is explained by the renowned "scholar" from Chicago, Al Capone, who sassist, "You have the right to get more via a type word and a gun than you deserve to via a type word alone."

In terms of the loving heart, can and should we combine our intellectual considerations once making romantic decisions, or have to we just follow our heart?

The problem is complex as although love is regarded to be irrational, the principle of finding the "right" perchild suggests a rational alternative. The dictate "to follow your heart and not your head" is in fact opposed to the rationality compelled in selecting the beloved, which must be based on the objective values we observe in the beloved. The conflict in between the two is articulated in myriad ways in our day-to-day life. Therefore, the following claim by a woman in love is typical of lovers" expressions: "Crazy love... That"s what it is... Nothing rational around it... Just crazy love." And in the TV series Ally McBeal, Renee tells Ally: "Emotionally, you"re an idiot." Lovers generally prefer their heart over their intellectual mind and also think about acting in accordance via their heart as the biggest expression of freedom and also honesty. Therefore, married people who have actually a forbidden romantic relationship might say that love is more substantial than outdated conventions, and letting their heart have the flexibility to select is even more genuine than being loyal to such conventions. In other instances, such a forbidden relationship permits human being to escape a poor marriage and in the name of love to produce a safe oasis external the house so regarding make home life even more tolerable.

For many civilization, avoiding yourself from adhering to your heart is no less of a sin than preventing your main partner from learning about all your actions. A woguy that had an virtual affair notes: "I dropped in love via this male digital. I felt like I was cheating on my fiancé, yet I assumed that my digital lover actually loved me even more than the man I had in my arms." Eva, a married woguy who is associated in a loving connection via a married man, sassist, "When I am through him, I feel as light as a feather, and whatever before we execute together feels so herbal and right." Eva"s use of the expression "natural and also right" might seem odd, as her behavior shows up to violate what various other human being might take into consideration as natural and also right-being faithful to your formal partner. But Eva is referring not to superficial circumstances however to the prouncovered mindsets and worths that underlie her intense love. Similarly, Bernard, that has actually been married for 15 years, says he considers the time his married lover spends through her husband as an exile from her genuine residence wright here her heart really desires to be. In fact, she constantly asks him to assist her endure "in the desert."

Many human being cherish the visibility of passionate love in their relationship and are "romantic" in the sense that they say that they would not marry a perchild that possessed every top quality they admire, however through whom they are not in love. The situation is more complicated as soon as civilization are required to divorce in order to follow their hearts. Here, the loss is obvious and the gain is yet to be checked out. The increase in the percentage of divorces indicates that more and also more people are providing currently better weight to their heart in such decisions.

Following our heart, however, might not always involve acting according to our character or moral norms. Our heart can expush a more limited facet of our character and also morality. Moreover, exactly how can we determine what the actual expressions of our heart are? Surely, not all emotional claims are real expressions of our deep loving attitudes-some of them are tentative expressions of superficial situations that we would certainly not desire to endure in the lengthy term. As Yehuda Ben-Ze"ev put it, "When is the yearning heart"s cry real? And when will certainly we be greeted by the true, and also hocolony, echo of love"s call? When does the response resonate falsely, and when does our speak to loss on deaf rock cliffs?" Our incapability to differentiate in between the 2 deserve to jeopardize those romantic decisions that depend specifically on our heart.

To sum up: Our heart indeed has actually a mind of its own; we have to listen to it, as it frequently expresses our profound perspectives, yet we should not always follow it without regard for rational considerations, because the intellectual mind is equally essential. If we have the right to learn to combine the two systems, we will certainly have the best of both worlds.

See more: Who Is A Good Man Is Hard To Find Protagonist In "A Good Man Is Hard To Find"?

The over considerations deserve to be encapsulated in the adhering to statement that a lover can express: "Darling, I know that adhering to your heart is challenging for you, as you cannot dismiss out on intellectual considerations. But remember that we just live when, and ignoring love deserve to permanently damage your heart. Sometimes, also time cannot heal a wounded heart."


Aaron Ben-Zeév, Ph.D., former President of the College of Haifa, is a professor of ideology. His publications include The Arc of Love: How Our Romantic Lives Change Over Time.