I was just wondering, how deserve to we differentiate "are you done?" and "have actually you done?", andwhat is the appropriate method to usage each?


*

*

Sorry to step in, but this question puzzles me also... just as a matter of clarification, deserve to we say that 'are you done?' is similar to 'have you finished?' but the initially one is normally complied with by with + noun or -ing develop, and the second by object or ing form? Thank you in advance!
"Are you done" asks around whether you have actually finished somepoint that you have actually started. "Have you done" likewise asks if you have actually finiburned, yet whether you have actually also began is unparticular.

You are watching: Are you done or are you finished

("Are you done" have the right to likewise be offered in a "correcting" or "accusatory" means, wbelow the asker knows complete well you haven"t started and that is the suggest he is trying to make. But that is not the normal instance.)


*

When asking "Have you done?", you are asking if the perchild did something in the past which could proceed to the current or have some implications to the current.

"Are you done?", on the various other hand also, actually suggests "have you finished?". That is, you are asking if the perkid completed the action started in the previous (even though such action might also have actually effects to the present).

See more: How To Do A Bump In Your Hair Inserts You'Ve, An Error Has Occured


*

"Are you done" is supplied when asking a perkid if he or she has actually finimelted doing something. The thing that is being done is well-known.

Are you done through washing the toilet?

"Have you done" is asked when the point being done is not known, and the person is inquiring regarding what the point is.

What exactly have you done to my car?

So, if you desire to ask if someone has actually finiburned doing somepoint, provided "are you done?", or "have you finished?" , yet not "have you done?"

Use "have you done" when asking around something that has happened, and you do not know. e.g. What have you done to him?


Share
Improve this answer
Follow
edited Jul 13 "11 at 2:12
answered Jul 13 "11 at 1:54
*

ThursagenThursagen
40.5k4343 gold badges161161 silver badges238238 bronze badges
1
Add a comment |
Highly active question. Earn 10 reputation (not counting the association bonus) in order to answer this question. The reputation necessity helps protect this question from spam and also non-answer activity.

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other inquiries tagged grammar distinctions present-perfect present-tense or ask your own question.


Featured on Meta
Linked
0
what is the definition of,Are you done?
182
How do the tens­es and as­pects in jiyuushikan.org cor­re­spond tem­po­ral­ly to one an­oth­er?
Related
2
How to usage "have been" and also be-verbs -- what's the distinction between them?
4
"For just how many days have actually you been there?"
0
"didn't must have actually done" or "needn't have done"
3
"Did you execute it?" vs "Have you done it?"?
0
Are “Why did you execute that” and also “Why have actually you done that” interchangeable?
3
What are the differences in between determicountry and motivation?
1
What is the distinction between Desire and Will?
Hot Network Questions even more warm questions
Question feed
Subscribe to RSS
Question feed To subscribe to this RSS feed, copy and paste this URL into your RSS reader.


jiyuushikan.org Language & Usage
Company
Stack Exadjust Network
website style / logo © 2021 Stack Exreadjust Inc; user contributions licensed under cc by-sa. rev2021.10.15.40479


jiyuushikan.org Language & Usage Stack Exadjust works ideal via JavaScript allowed
*

Your privacy

By clicking “Accept all cookies”, you agree Stack Exchange deserve to keep cookies on your device and also discshed information in accordance through our Cookie Policy.